Community

Community Is a Feeling—So What Are We Actually Building

“Community is a feeling. It happens when people feel like they belong and when the system quietly supports that without ever becoming the star of the show.”

Tasha Van Vlack

5 min read

There’s a phrase I hear over and over again when people describe the best community spaces they’ve ever been part of:

“I just felt in community there.”

No mention of platform.
No mention of KPIs.
Just a gut-level recognition of belonging.

But here’s the tension: most of us building community professionally aren’t designing feelings. We’re designing systems. We’re configuring software. We’re optimizing workflows, mapping user journeys, drafting onboarding copy, and trying to prove to funders or clients that this thing has value.

So what do we do with that disconnect?


Community Is a Feeling, But We’re Building Infrastructure

According to a 2023 report from Community Roundtable, 88% of community professionals say their communities create value—but only 12% say their organizations can actually measure it. That gap between impact and metrics? It mirrors this exact tension.

Community isn’t a dashboard metric. It’s not a feature. It’s a vibe. A felt sense of connection, alignment, and “I see you.”

Community isn’t a dashboard metric. It’s not a feature. It’s a vibe. A felt sense of connection, alignment, and “I see you.”

And yet, to build that feeling at scale—or even at consistency—we do need systems. We need a structure that doesn’t just support the feeling, but actually makes it possible in the first place.This is the paradox of community work:
We are building for something fundamentally intangible, using very tangible tools.

The Challenge of Personalizing What Can’t Be Productized

As Richard Millington of FeverBee puts it, “Community isn’t about engagement metrics, it’s about solving problems for people in a way that builds relationships, trust, and a habit of returning.” That’s the heart of the challenge: you can measure attendance or posts, but you can’t fake belonging.

When someone says they “feel in community,” what they often mean is:

When someone says they “feel in community,” what they often mean is:

  • I didn’t have to explain myself
  • I was safe to be a bit messy
  • I felt seen, not sold to
  • I could be useful, even in a small way

But replicating that? It doesn’t come from a checklist.

The moment we try to productize that feeling—”here’s our 6-step belonging funnel!”—we risk losing what made it feel real in the first place.

And yet, we also know that without intentional design, community drifts. People disengage. Energy evaporates.

So Where Does That Leave Us?

It leaves us in a space of tension. And honestly, that’s where the best community builders live.

At The Nonprofit Hive, we’ve had people describe a single 30-minute Hive Chat as “the most seen I’ve felt in months.” Not because we did anything magical. But because we removed barriers, designed lightweight systems, and then got out of the way.We use automation—but not to replace people. To free them up.
We use structure—but not to force outcomes. To create space for emergence.

Designing for the Feeling (Without Faking It)

Here’s the kicker: 76% of people say they’ve felt a sense of community in an online group, according to a 2022 survey by Facebook—but fewer than half felt confident that sense of connection would last. That’s our design challenge.

So how do you design for something you can’t quite measure?

So how do you design for something you can’t quite measure?
You look for signals, not proof:

  • Are people coming back?
  • Are they inviting others?
  • Are they showing up differently than they do elsewhere?

You create containers, not funnels.
You prioritize rhythms over rules.
You design with your members, not just for them.

Because community is a feeling. But it doesn’t happen by accident.

It happens when people feel like they belong—and when the system quietly supports that, without ever becoming the star of the show.

A Few Ways to Start Designing for the Feeling

1️⃣ Design Systems That Get Out of the Way
Build automation to reduce friction—not to replace the human parts. What’s one repetitive task you can systematize so you can spend more time actually talking to your members?

2️⃣ Look for Signals, Not Scale
Instead of asking “How many?” ask “How deep?” Pay attention to the moments people tell you they felt seen, heard, or welcomed. Build more pathways like that.

3️⃣ Create Containers That Invite Emergence
You don’t need a grand curriculum. You need a place where people feel safe enough to share, connect, and co-create what happens next.

4️⃣ Name the Vibe, Then Protect It
If someone says, “This feels different,” dig into why. Then make that part of the design—whether it’s how you onboard people, how you match them, or what expectations you set.For more on how to create sustainable, member-led engagement, check out Who’s Actually in Charge of Your Community?, where I unpack how control kills participation—and how trust builds it.

Final Thought

If you’re struggling to reconcile structure with soul, automation with authenticity—you’re not doing it wrong. You’re doing the real work of community building.

And the truth is, that feeling? Of being in the tension, of holding space for complexity, of walking the unscalable path on purpose?

That’s community, too.

If you’re struggling to reconcile structure with soul, automation with authenticity—you’re not doing it wrong. You’re doing the real work of community building.

And the truth is, that feeling? Of being in the tension, of holding space for complexity, of walking the unscalable path on purpose?

That’s community, too.


Want the rest of our lived + learned tips for designing real community in messy, human ways? Download the full Community Building Guidebook: https://gn7syrdv.sibpages.com/